Rums

This page links to all the rum reviews which are mainly based on samples, complete with scoring. After much correspondence, we all agreed to make our point-ratings the same. You can use the search engine on your right for more fun.

Name Year Sampled Average Score
Saint-James cuvée 250 ans 3 85,00
Neisson L'Esprit 3 81,67
Neisson Le Rhum par Neisson 3 76,00
Neisson 2004 2004 4 88,00
Neisson Extra Vieux 3 82,33
Berry Bros 1977 Jamaican rum 1977 1 90,00
Saint James 1932 1932 1 84,00
Montebello 1948 1948 1 89,00
Montebello 1948 55° 1948 1 92,00
Samaroli Port Morrant 1990 1990 1 79,00
Samaroli West Indies Dark Rum 1948 1948 1 94,00
Gordon & MacPhail 1941 1941 2 92,00
Bally 1993 1993 4 86,75
Bally 1982 1982 4 87,50
Bally 1960 1960 5 90,20
Bally 1975 1975 5 87,80
Bally 1979 1979 4 85,75
Bally 1992 1992 3 86,00
Appleton 50 3 87,67
Appleton Reserve 20 ceramic jug 60/70's 3 87,00
Wray & Nephew Private Stock 70's 2 86,50
Appleton Reserve 12 ceramic jug 60/70's 4 84,50
Appleton V/X circa 80/90 80/90 2 75,50
Appleton 21 90's 1999 3 78,33
Appleton Rare Old 12 70/80's 3 83,00
Appleton White circa 50/60 50/60's 1 80,00
Appleton Extra circa 80 80's 1 84,00
Havana Club Anejo 80's 80's 2 75,50
El Dorado 25yo 1980 1980 4 65,00
El Dorado 25yo 1986 1986 4 63,50
Alfred Lamb's 1939 special reserve 1939 2 80,50
Bacardi Facundo Paraiso 3 68,00
Black Jack Choice old Jamaica Rum circa 50 1 0,00
Appleton 21 1 60,00
Bacardi 6 yo Anejo Extra Special 1980s 3 73,67
rhum vieux de Castillos 1966 1 88,00
Velier Uitvlugt UF30E 1985 1985 6 90,83
Berry Bros Demerara 1975 1975 2 87,00
El Dorado Rare Collection Port Mourant 1999 1999 4 81,50
El Dorado Rare Collection Versailles 2002 2002 4 85,75
El Dorado Rare Collection Enmore 1993 1993 4 83,75
Damoiseau 1980 1980 2 87,00
Velier Damoiseau 1980 1980 2 90,00
Diplomatico Ambassador 3 63,67
Bristol Caroni 1974 1974 3 88,67
Black Joe Jamaican Rum circa 80 2 82,50
Velier Skeldon 1973 1973 6 89,50
Velier Uitvlugt 1997 1997 3 86,00
Neisson 21 1993 2 92,00
La Favorite Privilège circa 80 2 83,00
Black Tot 2 83,00
Bielle 2003 2003 2 87,50
Domaine de Courcelles 1972 2 84,50
English Harbour 1981 1981 1 74,00
St Nicholas Abbey 15 2 85,50
Habitation Velier Foursquare 2013 2013 3 85,33
Habtitation Velier Muller LL IV/3177 2015 2 78,00
Silver Seal Port Mourant 1975 1975 2 91,00
Silver Seal Port Mourant 1975 1975 2 88,00
Rum of the Lords ‘Freya’ 1982 1 88,00
Bally 6 ans circa 60 5 82,60
La Favourite 1990 AOC 1990 5 83,00
Saint James 1986 1986 3 85,00
Velier Caroni 1982 Full Proof Heavy Rum 1982 5 87,00
Velier Caroni 1985 Full Proof Heavy Rum 1985 4 87,25
Saint James 1885 1885 5 92,40
Velier Blairmont 1982 1982 5 87,60
Velier Diamond & Versailles 1996 1996 1 89,00
Sant Andrea 1939 1939 5 84,60
Velier Albion 1986 1986 5 90,20
Velier Port Mourant 1974 1974 5 91,60
Bielle 1994 1994 1 93,00
Velier Caroni 1974 1974 1 85,00
King of Diamonds circa 80 5 72,40
Nicholson Finest Trinidad Rum circa 60/70 5 80,80
Barbancourt 25 YO Reserve Veronelli circa 80 5 86,60
La Martiniquaise Rhum Pur 5 83,00
Barbancourt Reserve Du Domaine circa 70 4 84,75
Trois Rivieres 1977 1977 4 87,25

ADVANCED SEARCH

Age
Year
ABV
Name

234 Rum Ratings